Titles and Honorifics
Okay. I am going to go ahead and say it. I was up this
evening at 2:30 am upset about the events of last night. Right now, I am just
writing to sort out my thoughts and try to make sense out of this situation.
I went to prayer meeting last night in Second Life. Among
the persistent prayer requests was the pastor of a church whose congregants
visit us weekly to pray. What was once thought to be stage 3 renal failure was
in fact the result of a bad reaction to certain medications. So, we were all
very happy to hear this person had recovered. This is a lady who took over the
ministry of the church her husband previously served at before he passed. I
will call her Carlotta.
She and many of the people in this church have titles
attached to their names, which one can read above their heads. Senior Pastor
Carlotta. The folks who come to visit also have titles along with their names,
too. Senior Deaconess Desiree. Assistant Pastor Lindsay. Whatever. I generally
ignore the titles and just use their first names. Which is fine. Or so I
thought.
Before Carlotta came down with her illness and had to be
hospitalized several months ago, she confronted me in prayer meeting about why
I did not use the titles before the names. I said the answer is quite simple.
You are not my pastor. I thought the matter was settled. When Carlotta returned
last night, within two minutes, she started asking me in front of the group if
I call my doctors “Doctor,” when I go to visit them. I could see where this was
going really fast. She was trying to pin me with accusations of why I did not
address her and others with these pretentious titles. I said, “No, this is
wrong. How rude!” I then logged out before I could say things I could not take
back.
I never expected to be chased out of my own church’s prayer
meeting. I gave a little cheer “yay!” when I first arrived and saw Carlotta was
attending prayer again, after being gone for over two months. One might think
that her initial response might be “Thank you for your prayers and
steadfastness on my behalf while I was ill.” Nope. It was to sling crap at me.
I am truly hurt because I counted these folks as my friends. People who have
visited our prayer meeting weekly for nearly a year now. People I had prayed
for, and who had prayed for me.
There are a couple of things going on here, and some things
I think may be going on behind the scenes. First, this particular group has
been asked to leave more than one ministry in Second Life when they visited,
for various reasons. Most often it was because they were being overbearing.
They have a reputation.
Second, and I strongly object to this, Carlotta was
insisting on putting words into my mouth (hers and her followers titles) in
order for them to feel good about themselves. She was injecting her church's
practices upon us in doing so. This is the precisely what the alphabet crowd
does with pronouns. “You didn’t call me ‘they’ which is a microaggression.” It
is the exact same thing, and like Jordan Peterson, I absolutely will not stand
for anyone putting words into my mouth that I did not choose. I don’t care who
they are.
Third, Carlotta did this in front of everyone there. This is
not biblical correction. The first time one confronts another Christian, they
are to speak one on one with the person they have a grief with. (Which was not
done the first time, either.) The second time a Christian confronts another,
they are to bring an elder with them for corroboration. This was not done last
night, as well. It was a public attempt at correction and coercion, and it was
wrong. Even as a teacher, I know to praise in public and correct in private.
For a “pastor,” Carlotta does not seem to be following scripture in this
regard. I use this word in quotations since a pastor, biblically, should be the
husband of one wife.
This got me thinking. Since this accusation of “not using
titles” came out at the very beginning of prayer meeting last night, I wonder
if the group from this other church had a meeting ahead of time and discussed
what they were going to do. In other words, I wonder if the others were in on
it to set me up. If, so, this would sadden me greatly. Because it means their
titles and honorifics are more important than friendship, than fellowship, than
being humble, or treating others respectfully. Which is interesting in that
that is what they are accusing me of being- disrespectful.
If this is true, if Carlotta decided with others to go ahead
with this planned confrontation, it means that she is in sin, not just for
insulting me at my own church’s prayer meeting, but also for leading others in
participation of this deed.
This whole situation is absurd. I should not be writing
this. I guess they cannot leave it alone. I can’t help but consider that
perhaps Carlotta has been wounded in some way that keeps her from giving up her
precious titles, for her and for others. It’s hers, her one, her own, her only,
her precious... title. In case you are wondering, I do not respond well to
being asked to compromise my internal thoughts and values. In this case, being
asked to suck up to a prideful and grandiose heirarchy.
To sum it up, I think it is wrong for a church... who is
visiting another church's service on that church's land, to demand that they
observe the peculiarities of the visiting church's doctrine, and to question
and belittle one of the host church's members.
So, this means that I should pray for Carlotta. I will. This
also means that I need to examine myself, and my thoughts and actions. I need
to beware lest I go down a similar road. What is my own title, my own
honorific, that I cannot do without? My only answer to giving this up should be
“Yes, Lord.” My prayer is that I yield myself to You in all thoughts, all
things and in all ways.